
Why the global response to climate change is falling short
11/19/2026 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Why the global response to climate change is falling short
In a year scarred by deadly floods and heat waves, the planet’s global temperature is on the verge of surpassing a critical threshold. Horizons moderator William Brangham explores the dangerous nature of climate change and the seeming inability to address the crisis with Kate Marvel and Michael Mann, two research scientists who have long wrestled with this issue.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

Why the global response to climate change is falling short
11/19/2026 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
In a year scarred by deadly floods and heat waves, the planet’s global temperature is on the verge of surpassing a critical threshold. Horizons moderator William Brangham explores the dangerous nature of climate change and the seeming inability to address the crisis with Kate Marvel and Michael Mann, two research scientists who have long wrestled with this issue.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Horizons from PBS News
Horizons from PBS News is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipI'm William Brangham, and this is "Horizons."
Negotiators from around the world have been meeting for two weeks in Turkey, seeking some consensus about acting on climate change.
Meanwhile, in a year scarred by deadly floods and heat waves, the Earth's global temperature is about to overshoot a key threshold, the state of our climate, coming up next.
♪ Narrator: Support for "Horizons" has been provided by Steve and Marilyn Kerman, and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation.
Additional support is provided by Friends of the News Hour.
♪ This program was made possible by contributions to your PBS station from viewers like you.
Thank you.
From the David M. Rubenstein Studio at WETA in Washington, here is William Brangham.
Welcome to "Horizons."
Eleven years ago, nearly 200 nations reached a historic agreement to do everything possible to slow down the dangerous warming of our planet.
It was in Paris, at the same annual U.N.
climate conference that's wrapping up in Turkey right now.
Negotiators settled on trying to limit additional global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius, that's just under three degrees Fahrenheit, in order to stave off the worst impacts of climate change.
Without that tangible target, they argued, greenhouse gas pollution would continue to fill our atmosphere.
The Earth would see increasing droughts and heat waves, stressing our ability to grow food and making many parts of the planet uninhabitable.
A warming planet would also create dangerous, destructive floods and storms, driving people from their homes and costing billions of dollars in damages.
By almost all measures, we're going to overshoot that 1.5-degree target and warm the planet even more.
And the tragedies, predictable as they are, continue to pile up.
Just one recent example.
Three months ago, in Nepal, a mountain glacier, weakened by warming temperatures and other factors, collapsed.
It sent a deadly torrent of water, ice and debris through a valley and killed over 1,300 people.
Given the dangerous nature of climate change, and the seeming inability of global talks to address this crisis, we wanted to turn today to two research scientists who have long wrestled with this issue.
Kate Marvel is the senior climate scientist at Project Drawdown, which is a research group that focuses on climate solutions.
For over 10 years, she was a research physicist at NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies.
And last year, she published the book "Human Nature, Nine Ways to Feel About Our Changing Planet."
Michael Mann is one of the country's preeminent climate scientists.
Trained as a climatologist and geophysicist, he is the presidential distinguished professor at the University of Pennsylvania, where he also directs the Penn Center for Science, Sustainability and the Media.
His most recent book, co-authored with Dr.
Peter Hotez, is "Science Under Siege."
Kate and Michael, so good to have you on the program.
Thank you for being here.
Michael, to you first.
As I mentioned, we are most likely going to blow past this 1.5 degree Celsius target that was set out in the Paris agreements.
This was admittedly a political target.
It's not a meaningful scientific target.
So does it matter that we're going to blow past that?
Yeah, thanks, William.
It's good to be with you.
It's, you know, we sometimes put too much emphasis on these specific numbers.
We make it sound like 1.5 Celsius, as you said, roughly three degrees Fahrenheit is some sort of climate cliff that we go off and all hope is lost if we exceed it.
And that's just not the way it is.
It's much more like a dangerous highway that we are going down.
And the further we go down the highway, the more danger we will encounter.
And we may miss, it now looks, the 1.5 Celsius exit.
That doesn't mean that we drive all the way to Toledo.
We get off at the next exit.
And right now there's a lot of discussion about what that is.
How much warming can we realistically hold the planet to and still avoid much of the harm and danger and mortality that we will encounter if we continue down this dangerous highway?
And Kate Marvel, what would your... similar question to you.
Do you think that this is a meaningful failure or is this just, as Michael is saying, one more step on the road?
I think it's both.
I think it's a meaningful failure because exceeding 1.5 is a real warning sign that we are not moving fast enough on reducing emissions.
I completely agree with Michael that nature doesn't think in Fahrenheit or Celsius.
There is nothing special about the 1.5 degree limit, just as there's nothing special about the two degree or three degree or four degree limit.
What we do know is that every tenth of a degree of warming matters and every ton of greenhouse gas emissions that we can prevent matter.
Michael, I know you're saying this is just, "Let's not get to Toledo," as you were putting it, but how do we not see this?
Mann: My apologies to the Toledo people.
I didn't mean to single them out.
That's quite all right.
It's a lovely city.
How do we not see this, though, as a colossal failure of international negotiations?
I mean, 200 nations said, "We are going to do everything we can to do this," but in the ensuing decade, emissions have continued to go up.
Temperatures have continued to go up.
I want to read the opening sentence of a paper that you were recently an author on.
You wrote, quote, "We are witnessing the rapid destabilization "of the Earth's climate system.
"This is no longer a warning for the future.
"It is a diagnosis of the present."
How do we not see this as an enormous failure?
Well, it is an enormous failure, as Kate said, and we have locked in far more damage, far more suffering because of the relative inability that we've demonstrated to decrease carbon emissions fast enough.
Five years ago, COP26, there was reason for optimism.
The countries of the world had all agreed to fairly stringent decreases in fossil fuel burning that had the potential to hold planetary temperatures well below two degrees Celsius.
It was substantial progress.
Since then, we haven't seen much additional progress, and we need to see more progress.
Two degrees Celsius is still too much warming of the planet.
1.5 Celsius warming, which we're already nearly at, look, we don't have to speculate as to what sort of harm we will see.
We're seeing it.
We are seeing catastrophic climate impacts now.
Every summer with the heat domes and the wildfires and the floods and the super storms that we experience here in the United States, we all witnessed the horror of what transpired in Europe this past summer and, of course, that Nepal collapse, which was an example of more than 1,000 people who died because of climate change.
We can clearly connect the dots there and with many of these catastrophic events.
So, look, we've already warmed the planet too much, and now it's about decarbonizing, moving away from fossil fuel burning as quickly as possible.
We're not seeing the progress we need to see at these conferences.
And we can talk about how the rules might have to be revised, so that a single bad actor, say, Saudi Arabia or Russia, can't essentially block any meaningful agreement for the rest of the world.
Brangham: Kate, I know that you have spoken about... The focus on international negotiations maybe misses the point a little bit, that there are individual examples, China, which is a complicated one, but a real one of renewable energy taking hold.
Do you hold some sense of hope that individual actors on this planet will get us there?
Well, I think it's a both and, right?
So, we know that greenhouse gases are well mixed in the atmosphere.
And what that means is that it doesn't matter where they're emitted.
It doesn't matter who emits them.
A ton of greenhouse gas emitted in China warms the planet exactly the same as a ton of greenhouse gas emitted by the United States.
So, there is an inherent international nature to this problem that does have to be addressed on an international level.
That said, the solutions are necessarily local.
We know exactly what is causing climate change.
It's our emission of greenhouse gases.
And we know exactly the sectors that are emitting greenhouse gases.
And I think the good news is that we have solutions for almost every sector, almost every human activity that emits carbon dioxide or methane or fluorinated gases.
We know how to stop doing that.
And so, it's a real scale problem where, yes, it is an international problem, but the actions that need to be taken are necessarily at the national or regional or local level.
Well, Kate, just staying with you for a second, tell us what those solutions are, what are we talking about?
Wind and solar and battery power.
What else?
So, I think it helps to actually look at the breakdowns of where emissions are coming from.
We know that about a quarter are coming from the power sector.
And that's where those technologies that you just named can be really helpful.
We know that about a quarter come from the way that we farm and the way that we use land.
And those cannot be mitigated just by stopping fossil fuels.
Stopping fossil fuels is a necessary but not sufficient condition to solving climate change.
We know that the transportation sector is a substantial contributor to emissions.
And we know how to decarbonize... we know how to decarbonize transportation.
We know how to decarbonize many, many, many industrial processes that currently emit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases.
And so, I guess my point is that there is no one silver bullet solution, no one knob that we press that's going to decarbonize everything overnight.
Instead, it's a whole array of different solutions, all of which are possible and most of which are actually cost effective right now.
Michael, I just want to tick through a couple of the remarkable metrics that demonstrate this renewable revolution.
Global energy production, 43% of that is now coming from renewable energy.
Global energy investment, this is all coming from Ember Energy, the think tank.
About $2 trillion invested in renewable energy, which is now double the investments in fossil fuels.
Hundreds thousand new solar panels going almost up every day across Africa.
EVs have gone from 2% of market share to now almost 18%.
Again, do those feel to you like we are on the way to really solving this?
Is it just a matter of pushing harder on those?
How do you see that?
Yeah, and I'll add another statistic.
87% of all added power generation capacity last year was from renewable energy.
So, it's clear that we are making tremendous progress.
The irony is that we're not yet making enough progress.
Both of those things can be true at the same time.
We are still relying heavily upon legacy fossil fuel sources for power, for transportation, as Kate was saying.
And there are existing solutions.
The irony here is that we have the technology to decarbonize our world.
The obstacles that we face aren't physical.
They're not the physical climate system.
We know that, if we stop emitting carbon, we can bring the warming of the planet to a halt.
It's not physical, it's not technological.
We've got the solutions to decarbonize our world.
The obstacles are entirely political.
And that's where individuals, once again, are important in the sense that we can engage in collective action.
We can use our voices and our votes.
And we saw in the midterm elections that people turned out in force.
People who care about the sort of the long-term sustainability of our world and our environment and issues like climate change turned out in force.
And that had a dramatic impact on our sort of the policy environment that we now find ourselves in, where there's an opportunity for meaningful policy progress on climate.
So yes, the individual action is critical.
But in my view, the most important individual action is participating in collective action that puts pressure on our policy makers to take the actions that we can't take ourselves.
To help move us away, provide incentives to move us away from fossil fuels towards renewable energy and other climate-friendly practices.
Okay, just picking up on what Michael is saying there, I know you're not a political scientist, you're a physicist.
But did you detect a climate signal in this last election?
Because it wasn't really mentioned as a topic.
Certainly, granted, this is not a national election.
These are mostly local elections.
But did you get a sense that people were in some way motivated by a desire for change in that regard?
So, yeah, you are absolutely right that I'm not a political scientist.
I just read the news the same as everybody else.
And what I've been picking up in the news is, yeah, candidates aren't talking about climate.
They're talking about affordability.
They're talking about corruption.
To a lesser extent, they're also talking about clean air, clean water, better health.
And all of those things actually are climate.
When we talk about climate solutions, I think there is a real case to be made that it's not just about the climate.
These things are cheaper, they're better, they're healthier.
And so in the jargon, we say they have co-benefits.
And so when we talk about affordability and we talk about moving away from fossil fuels, those are actually the same thing.
And so this is probably a hot take that I'm going to get in trouble for, but I'm not that bothered that candidates aren't using the words "climate change."
What I care about is action.
And I think now there are so many reasons for action.
There are so many motivations that lead us down the right path that I don't think we need to use particular words.
Michael, I want to ask you about this same issue.
According to Pew of a poll they put out recently, there is increasing pessimism amongst Democrats and Republicans that, again, people in both political parties saying they don't think anything meaningful will be done to address climate change.
You don't think they're right?
You don't think that sense of pessimism is warranted?
Well, you know, there is a sense of pessimism that arises from sort of an understandable cynicism with the political process, given everything that we've witnessed over the past two years.
And I think that, to some extent, that sort of that pervasive, gloomy thinking is a product of, you know, a very challenging political environment that we have found ourselves in for two years.
It's understandable that people have sort of lost their sense of agency.
It just feels like all the problems that we face are too big to do anything about.
And those who are in power are not only uninterested in solving the problems in the current case, they're actually creating these problems.
So it's understandable.
At the same time, it's also important to understand, you know, that we do have agency.
And this election was a good example of that.
And I'll just pick up on some points that Kate made, with which I agree very much, although I put a sort of a fine point on it.
If you look at the issues that voters cared most about, as Kate said, affordability.
But affordability, prices, transportation prices are being driven up because of a foreign war of choice by the president that was really about maintaining access to fossil fuels.
And we are seeing the disruption of supply chains and distribution systems by extreme weather events.
That's driving inflation as well.
And so when people talk about affordability, when they talk about inflation, there's a clear climate impact there.
There are the policies of the current administration that have canceled clean energy projects at the last minute when they were nearly finalized.
And the administration has provided incentives to energy producers to scrap renewable energy projects and instead double down on fossil fuels.
And that is driving up energy prices as well, because fossil fuels on a levelized basis are the least expensive form of energy.
You take that out of the mix, you're going to drive up energy prices.
So one of the things that I've been advising some political candidates is to try to connect the dots here.
Yes, it's about affordability.
It's about inflation.
It's about an unpopular war of choice.
It's about data centers, which ultimately, we just learned in a report the other day, have a larger carbon footprint than we realized.
All of these things are about energy and climate.
And it's time for politicians to connect the dots, because some of the solutions, some of the actions that we might take to combat any one of these things are not the same as the solutions that we would pursue if we recognize that there is one underlying problem, crisis that is creating all of these problems.
And that's the climate crisis.
Kate, I want to pivot back for a second to climate science.
People will often hear in the press this concern that as the planet continues to warm, we approach what are called tipping points.
Help people understand that.
What do we mean when we say tipping points?
What are those?
I think that's a great question.
I have found that there's a lot of confusion in the popular discourse.
A lot of times, people mix up what we as climate scientists think of as feedbacks and tipping points.
So let me try to clarify.
A feedback is a climate change that happens in response to global warming, but then feeds back on that global warming that either makes it better or worse.
The easiest feedback for me to understand is what we call the ice feedback.
We know that when it gets hotter, ice melts.
Ice is really shiny and so very reflective.
When you melt the ice and you expose that darker ground underneath, that means that the earth absorbs more sunlight and that makes it warmer.
So that's an example of a destabilizing feedback.
And that's something that's happening in the background right now.
Now, a lot of times when we talk about tipping points, what we actually mean is something that we break, that we cannot fix in a human lifetime or even a civilizational lifetime.
So something like breaking up an ice sheet.
That is not something that we are going to be able to refreeze on any time scales that are relevant to us.
And so when we think about tipping points in the climate system, yes, we know they're there.
There are aspects of this beautiful, complex earth system that we can break.
And we can break essentially forever.
And the scary part for me is that we don't know exactly the warming threshold at which we will exceed these tipping points, at which we will tip them over.
So we can't say if we limit warming to well below two degrees, for example, that we're safe.
But at the same time, we can't say that, "Oh, we're doomed if we pass a particular threshold."
So a tipping point is something to be very, very worried about.
But it's not necessarily something that can be prevented by keeping warming below a particular level.
All we know is, again, every tenth of a degree of warming matters.
The extent to which we can limit warming to as little as possible is the best way to prevent breaching any number of these tipping points.
Michael, how do you think about those?
Again, Kate is describing civilizational things being broken at a timescale that we can't put back together.
Humpty Dumpty will not go back together in these regards.
How do you think about those issues?
We have about two and a half minutes left.
Yeah, you know, I can't improve on the characterization that Kate provided there.
What I would say is that in some ways it's sort of like there's a field, there's a minefield.
And we don't know where those mines are.
But we know that walking out onto that minefield is likely going to result in catastrophe.
And the only sensible thing to do is to stop that forward lurch onto this dangerous minefield.
Now, there are tipping points with respect to the climate system, with respect to ice sheet collapse, with respect to altered ocean currents that could have a profound impact on regional climates.
The release of methane as we warm the planet is another one of those potential tipping-point-like responses.
The only sensible strategy to avoid them is to stop the warming of the planet, to stop the actions that continue to warm up the planet.
And I would put one other sort of... I would make one other connection here.
There are the climate tipping points and then there are societal tipping points, where, if we breach a certain level of warming, it sets in motion a whole set of changes in our basic infrastructure and our sort of socio-political system that creates even greater and potentially irreversible dangerous impacts on all of us.
And so there is one tipping point, however, that is actually a positive tipping point.
And that's the tipping point in public consciousness.
As we recognize the threat that we face and hopefully find it within ourselves to take the actions that are necessary, we can dramatically change our policy infrastructure.
We can move dramatically towards a cleaner, better world driven by renewable energy.
It's all possible.
It's just a matter of us collectively realizing that we can do it and achieving that sort of socio-political tipping point in consciousness.
Kate, in the last 30 seconds we have, imagine our audiences watching these headlines about the failure of international talks again to move the needle.
What would you like people to be thinking about as they see those headlines?
I think a lot of times people ask me, "Oh, is there any hope that we can solve climate change?"
And for me, that's fundamentally the wrong question.
That's like asking, do you hope you can clean your bathroom?
I don't know.
Just clean your bathroom.
You know what to do.
And we know what to do.
We have the climate solutions that we need.
All we need is to really get to work.
Brangham: Kate Marvel, Michael Mann, so great to talk to you both.
Thank you both very much for being here.
Both: Thank you.
And that's it for this episode of "Horizons."
Thank you so much for watching.
We'll see you next week.
Narrator: Support for "Horizons" has been provided Steve and Marilyn Kerman and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation.
Additional support is provided by Friends of the News Hour.
♪ This program was made possible by contributions to your PBS station from viewers like you.
Thank you.
♪ You're watching PBS.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.

New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by: